Sounds really stupid, but that's the kind of feeling I got from the recent presbytery meeting from the folks I disagree with. It's the usual response from folks I accuse of being an "ist" , how can I be a racist? Some of my best friends are minorities! (a term used for the majority of the people in the world!) I can't be a sexist! Some of my best friends are women. I can't be homophobic because.... you get the message. Many of my colleagues have written very good posts of the recent meeting held on April 21 where this community of faith called San Francisco Presbytery voted down an amendment that would give each church the right to discern who their ordained leaders of the church will be. Read posts of my colleagues the Rev. InHo Kim and the Rev. Monte McClain who say it better than I can.
Before going to the Presbytery meeting, I had a feeling of dread that this church will continue excluding people called by God to serve the church. PCUSA's constitution was changed 75 years ago so that women could be ordained as deacons and elders and 50+ years ago the first woman was ordained as a Minister of Word and Sacrament. But just because they made those changes doesn't mean that every church "HAS" to hire a woman. In fact there are many churches who WILL NOT hire a woman as their pastor, just because... During the Civil Rights movement, the church also started supporting the calling pastors of color, again, doesn't mean that the church HAS to hire a person of color. I am a woman of color over the age of 50 and glad that the faith community I serve discerned that my gifts, talents, and love for Jesus the Christ matched their gifts, talents and love for Christ.
Calling a pastor is a matter of discernment between the church and God. Every church has the right to call whomever they discern God has chosen for them. EXCEPT if the person is of a different sexual orientation-meaning same gender loving people.
I support the ordination of all people called by God, who have met all the requirements of the church, has common sense (I know a misnomer), has passion for Jesus and has discerned with the church that "this is the place God calls me to." And even when the church ordains the "right" people, they screw up, there are more sexual harassment cases in our presbyteries by our "normal" folks that would make one wonder how they got called. That's right we are only human!!!
Many of my friends have switched to the open and inclusive UCC church and have asked why don't you just leave and become one of us. I love the Presbyterian Church USA. I was baptized by this church and my memories and deep gut love for the church comes from my relationship with my home church Trinity, Stockton. I am going to hang in there with the PCUSA and do my best to bring about an inclusive church until they ask me to leave or kick me out!!!
Here is the letter from Pam Byers, Executive Director of the Covenant Network that shares her reflections of what happened that night:
Dear friends,
I hardly know how to report to those of you who weren't at the
presbytery meeting tonight the very sad news that for the first time
since 1994, our
presbytery voted against a more inclusive vision of the church. The
vote tonight on Amendment 08-B was 167 Yes - 177
No, with 4 abstentions.
I am glad, at the same time, to share the good news that the three
other presbyteries voting today all voted Yes, including two who voted
No the last
time around. (We have the very unhappy distinction of being the first
to switch in the wrong direction.)
While I expected the vote in San Francisco to be very close, I am
still stunned, heart-sick, and hard put to explain our result. We
know
of (too
many!) friends who were out of town or sick, though I also saw several
who I know made sacrifices to be there (thank you!)
I certainly
did see numbers of ministers there tonight who I strongly suspect were
No voters, and whom I have never seen at presbytery before. The
location
at Walnut Creek (otherwise admirable hosts) certainly didn't help -
though I still hoped we could pull it off.
I do think
we were very well served by our three excellent speakers for 08-B - Max Lynn, pastor of St John's, Berkeley; elder Ricky Choi of Mission Bay Community church; and Keenan Kelsey, pastor of Noe Valley Ministry here
in the City. (Warm thanks to all three, who I know invested many hours in being articulate, persuasive, and brief!)
The evening portion of the meeting, which included our
consideration and vote on 08-B, was surrounded by a really lovely
worship service planned and
led by pastor Judy Durff from Lafayette-Orinda and our presbytery
moderator, elder Chuck Fry, with a gorgeous choral group from LOPC. We
concluded with the Lord's Supper, after the vote was announced. We
ended the service and the meeting in a huge circle around the
sanctuary.
Looking around that circle, I recognized so many colleagues, from
different contexts - and by the grace of God was able to remember that
Christ died
and rose for all of us.
We beguiled the time while the votes were being
counted with hymns. Immediately before the results were announced we
sang "Great Is Thy
Faithfulness," which includes the promise of "strength for today, and bright hope for tomorrow." That is what I
lean on right now.
Please continue in prayer for our whole church, and especially for the
six "swing" (meaning unpredictable) presbyteries that will vote in the
next
week: Boise, de Cristo, Detroit, Lehigh, Northern Plains, and Sierra
Blanca. If you have friends in any of them, please do call them with
a word of encouragement and exhortation. And hold them and our whole
church in prayer!
We had many friends there tonight very personally and directly affected
by our vote; and I drove the most visible one, Lisa Larges, home. I
deeply grieve for their hurt and loss. I grieve even more for the cost
to our congregations of not being able officially to welcome their
ministry. I grieve most of all for the hugely un-evangelical message
our vote may send to people who need to hear a saving invitation from
Christ.
We have a lot of work still to do in the church
and in our own presbytery. I am grateful indeed to share it with all
of you. And I'm more
grateful still to be confident that the Risen Christ will continue to
lead us forward. As my dear colleague Tricia often says, The Gospel is inevitable. Thanks be to God!
Faithfully (though sadly) yours,
Pam
Elder, Old First Presbyterian Church, San Francisco, and
Executive Director, Covenant Network of Presbyterians
2515 Fillmore Street • San Francisco, CA 94115
415 351 2196 (phone) • 415 351 2198 (fax)
www.covenantnetwork.org
Recent Comments